Indian rupee (₹) has been on a constant free fall for a
couple of months against basket of international currencies.
The ₹ has tumbled by more than 12 percent against
the U.S dollar since March, however has nosedived 27 percent since last July,
one of the biggest decline among Asian Currencies.
This week ₹ hit all time low against the $ to ₹ 56.37 (24th May 2012), however
managed to appreciate somewhat at closing week session at ₹ 55.50.
November 2011, when I was at job
interview, the interviewer asked me: what is your expectation on ₹? I
replied, I am pessimistic on ₹, at least
for a year or so. If ₹ will touch
to 56 or 57 against dollar, I won’t be surprised because of the gloomy internal
environment and external economic setting (I was referring the EU debt crisis,
US economic concern and overcast world scenario). The interviewer smiled gaily and put
forward his optimistic view on ₹, which I
felt, he might be true assuming at his expertise.
(It
was just before couple of years; ₹
was trading proudly at a range of ₹
42-45, vis-à-vis to a huge GDP growth, high FDI and FII inflows)
Why the Indian rupee once termed as the highly
demanded currency just before a year ago is on constant free fall? The questions
has mugged the sentiment of millions people who are directly or indirectly
impacted by the depreciation of INR.
I believe
following are the key reasons:
Indian Internal Economic Environment
The value of INR is derived by the free float
in the international environment, i.e demand vs supply. Higher the demand of ₹, higher the appreciation and vice-versa. The
demand and supply of currencies are impacted by various micro and macro economic
situation of the nation. Few but noteworthy economic grounds are:
India is experiencing huge TRADE DEFICIT during the current period. Trade deficit
happens when the total national value of IMPORT is superior to the EXPORT.
However, when Export is higher than Import, it is called as Trade Surplus.
The trade deficit during 2011-12 went up to
$185 billion, the higher ever in the country’s history, though export grew by
20%, import rose at a quicker pace. The fiscal deficit (including current and
capital account of nation) in 2011-12 was at 5.9% of GDP as against projection
of 4.6%. Amid the higher trade deficit, the foreign exchange reserve of India
has slipped from $332 billion to $ 293 billion since last August.
When there is higher import, the importers tends
to demand the foreign currency for trade, especially dollar. The higher demand
of dollar, definitely leads to the appreciation of dollar value as against the
local currency (₹). Hence, the value of ₹ plunges down, whereas the value of foreign
currency appreciates.
THE CAPITAL INFLOW in Indian economy was astonishing for the
year 2009 and 2010. However, it shrank thereafter. India as a developing nation
attracted bounty of foreign direct investments, NRI investments, Foreign Institutional
Investors, Remittance and such forth. According to data, during 2011-12 India
received $30 billion in FDI, in addition to a net inflow of $18 billion from
FIIs investors in stocks and bonds.
But, uncertainty about India’s political hassles
on economic reform, retrospective tax issues, high inflation, government’s
policies and waning GDP have forced
foreign investors to postpone their investment decision until the good news
arrives or take money out of Indian capital market and invest elsewhere for
safe and profitable return.
Consequently, the lower supply of foreign
currency in the Indian economy, frequent conversion of ₹ for $ on capital
flight have added the overcast on value of ₹.
THE GDP GROWTH RATE AND HIGH INFLATION has added the extra reason for ₹ depreciation to
such low level. The Indian impressive growth story is an example to the world
economic progress. It grew on an average of 9% before 2010-11, however slid
down to less than 7% on 2011-12 and expected not too encouraging figure for
2012-13.
Uncle inflation has been horrifying guest for
long in every Indian household. It was not long before Indian inflation was on
double digit, which cooled off for some time. The ongoing rise in fuel price,
high food and vegetable prices, imbalance liquidity problem has boosted the
surge in inflation again and expected to prevail at double digit again this
year if the government’s policies failed to control the economic balance.
Because of higher inflation, looming GDP
growth and other issues, most foreign investors as well as Indian citizens prefer
to invest abroad or keep the money away from Indian investment which has added
selling pressure on ₹.
SPECULATION ON ₹ has also led to
the devaluation of local currency. When ₹ was exchanging at
around 50 against the dollar, many experts, economists and pundits believed it
was the point of resistance. However, ₹ went on
depreciating. Pundits again forecasted, it will rest at 53 or 54. During the
period, RBI did a hell lot of effort to establish ₹ from further
plunge. Various strategies were put forward by RBI, nevertheless things only
cooled off for short time.
When currency
traders and speculators realized that the job done by RBI has unable to manage
the exchange rate at appropriate level, the selling pressure on ₹ swell up, as a
result the devaluation on ₹ was obvious. The worst part is, those pundits
who predicts ₹ to limit at 53 or 54 against the dollar, is expecting to hover around
the level of 60.
THE POLITICAL SETTING of India
has been acting as a hurdle for an economic growth. Though I am not a political
proficient, but I can sense the ongoing scenario on political arena impeding
the economic progress. Various scams and fraudulent activities, government’s
rigidity on accomplishing pending bills for economic benefits, less focusing on
economic activities vis-à-vis to political vested interest, higher inflation on
food and fuel prices have dampened the sentiment of national sovereign as well
as foreign nationals. Which, on the other side have added the depreciating
value of ₹.
EXTERNAL ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT
After the sub-prime
crisis that started in US (2008) and extended to rest of the world, the world
economic growth has been on sluggish trend. More of awful news have been on
headlines rather than motivating one.
However, Indian economic grew substantially well in comparison to its counterparts after initial free fall. At a time when Indian market was looking perfectly fine, THE EU DEBT CRISIS dampened the sentiment.
However, Indian economic grew substantially well in comparison to its counterparts after initial free fall. At a time when Indian market was looking perfectly fine, THE EU DEBT CRISIS dampened the sentiment.
The EU Debt Crisis,
particularly on Greece has been a point of worry not only for Greece or Europe
but to the whole world. The countries such as Ireland, Spain, Portugal is also
suffering from huge debt issues. Huge debt, high un-employment, meager growth
story, economic imbalance and limited solution to boost the economic growth and
sentiment on these European countries have directly hampered the Indian
economy, which is one of the key trade partners.
The slow growth
story of US, Europe crisis, Japanese struggle to gain its economic feat, poor
data mounting from China and worries about global economic slowdown has fanned
the fears further.
How the global slowdown
including mounting problem on Greece has aggravated the value of Indian
currency? The answer is simple to understand but vague to presume for the
solution. The slowdown on Europe has depreciated the value of single currency
EURO against basket of foreign currency, making dollar strong and safe haven.
The
global economy paralyzed on poor participation of various strong economies. The
demands for various goods and services have slowed down. Indian export to those
ailing economic destination suffered a setback, rise in oil import and other
material imports surpassed the export value of India forcing trade deficit to
mount high. Investor’s sentiment has been on low level. The value of Indian
rupee was suffered due to those entire phenomenons by some or other way.
During the last
three month, ₹ depreciated by more than 12% versus the U.S dollar. Nevertheless, the
global economic factors played havoc not only with the ₹ but also with
other foreign currencies. Brazil’s currency slides by 15%, South Africa’s
currency devaluated by 10%, Euro too depreciated against the dollar, however
Chinese Yuan, which is heavily controlled by government’s manipulation
depreciated by just 0.43 percent.
Does Rise in US Dollar Meant,
US Economy is at Strong helm???
If we look at the US
GDP amount, the answer will be YES, pretty powerful enough. However if we look
forward the growth rate after 2008 crisis the sentiment will turned grim. The US
economy just grew less than 3% since then and expected to grow at 2% on current
year. US’s outstanding public debt currently stood above 100% of GDP, while its
federal deficit for fiscal year 2012 amounted to $1.2 trillion, i.e. approx 9%
of GDP. Its current account deficit hit $437 billion in 2011, i.e. 3.2 percent
of GDP. Trade deficit is more than $500 billion.
In comparison with
the US economy, India's GDP is expected to grow by around 7 percent, while its
public debt to GDP ratio was a far lower at 66 percent in 2010-11. The
country's economic metrics are much better than the US' and yet the rupee is
weakening against the dollar. Obviously, it’s the sentiment playing game as Gandhi
note given as risky asset class and safe haven status to the greenback ($).
My Expectation on Future Value
of Rupee
The research on success rate of Pundit’s predictions is just a meager of 1%, i.e. 99% forecasts just bullshit. However, I am not predicting as any kind of Pundit but as a layman or simply an enthusiastic MBA-Finance student.
Given a time frame of one year, if ₹ would touch to
maximum of 59 against the $, I won’t be too surprised. The ongoing creepy
economic environment together with high inflation, fiscal deficit, taxation issues, lack of government’s
enthusiasm on stabilizing the economy and political brawl before central
election will be my logical reason.
Not only this, the European debt issues is
not going to solve sooner, the poor data from china will continue to dampen the
sentiment, surge on crude oil price will weigh down the Indian economy, U.S
won’t get huge economic boost but will act as Ghost Machine to hunt ₹ by some or other
means.
Nonetheless, I believe at short term the value
of ₹ may appreciated to certain
level (say up to 52 or 53) against the dollar due to the RBI act on controlling
mechanism (How RBI Controls Currency Exchange Fluctuation, will be my next
article). But, again I am pessimistic for a given one year period at
the exchange rate of ₹ vs. $.
Hope I will be wrong and ₹ will stabilized soon against the dollar and basket of foreign
currencies. The standard exchange rate supports exceedingly for overall
economic progress, hope India will achieve this feat ASAP, which indeed
benefits the billion of people.
GOOD LUCK!!!!
By: Bikash "BGN"
For: www.bgnir.blogspot.com
Data and
references have been abstracted from bbc.com, Economictimes.com,
moneycontrol.com, reuters.com.



