April 04, 2010

Equity Market: Present Situation and Solution



Securities Board of Nepal and Nepal Stock Exchange jointly organized an interaction program on Sunday inviting various market experts, participants from investor's associations, former SEBON chief, representatives from banking and development bank association along with two representatives from CDSL India limited.

The interaction program was primarily based on "Equity Market, present situation and key solutions", which started at 9 am at Hotel Del' Annapurna with report presentation by market expert Dipesh Baidhya (Manager, VIBOR Bank). In his presentation, Vaidya burrow up the prime reasons behind the market downhill and solutions to encounter such problems. Vaidya pin point the liquidity crunch, feeble economic growth, lacking of long-term investors, deficient of less option for investment rather that financial stocks that hold more than 70% of total listed shares, and short of other investment tools as preference share, debentures etc. were forcing market plummets. Likewise, lengthy transaction process for share certificate, weak public information dissemination system, geographic un-reach to mass investors and speculation rather that long-term investors also hindered the market growth.


He suggested that, the wise decision to bring the long-term investors as well as institutional investors, dissemination of quick and true information to investors, co-ordination among regulatory boards leaving their vested interest in one side, implementation of CDS system, bringing mutual funds, training to market intermediaries, adding brokerage firms and expanding market horizon efficiently will definitely boost the market health as well as investor confidence.

In the same way, other speakers also dig out the reasons behind the intrinsic bears after the strong bulls and emphasized what should be done recently to uplift the market sentiment.

Jhapat Bohara, President Development Bank Association

The present economic situation is the basis for market downhill, if economy, investment environment and political happening are pessimistic how stock market alone can will outperform the market, he questioned. He added that, extremely loss Balance of Payment (BOP), high inflation, weak remittance (10 to 15% growth in comparison to previously 50-70%), horizon in investment portfolio as gold, commodities market, real sector, bank deposits, anti-money laundering provision by government, frequently changing government and its policies has held back the stock performance.
He suggested, capital gain tax should levied in two ways:  short term and Long terms and there should also be provision for tax benefit in dividend less than Rs. 5000, margin lending on the basis of stock risk with maximum of 70% to minimum of 40% and 100% renewal system for such loan. He too focused on bringing the institutional investors, mutual funds, independent credit rating agency and strong co-ordination between the regulators is essential for capital market enhancement.

Sashin Joshi, President Nepal Bankers Association

Sashin Joshi emphasized on the co-ordination and the working together system from the regulatory board as (SEBON, MOF, NEPSE, NRB, and Insurance Board etc.) will help market sentiment to grow in positivity. However, he poured a distinct view in the market saying "the market is the correction of the bubble bull market and the financial indicators as P/E ratios, P/B ratios proved it". The government has failed to bring the large corporate house, many hydropower companies, institutional investors as well as long-term investors in stock trading, hence need to do homework to attract such companies as well as investors in near term for market expansion.

"If at recently, the bond of political parties will pledge to work for economic development than surely the economic environment, investment trust as well as capital markets will get a big bonanza however, the words should be started with initial actions".
He too added that "the banks are facing high liquidity crunch, less deposits from customers and high inflation rate hence the high interest rate has been implemented" which is certainly not good for the banks and shareholders itself. He speaks in favor of brining promoters share to the market, opposed the increment in margin lending will boost share prices along with lack of long-term perspective in investors and investors are following right and bonus share that has no value formation in long-term.

Investor's Association

Representative from three investors' forum as "General Investors Association of Nepal, Nepal Investment Forum and Nepal Securities Investor Association" expressed their deep concerns on their agreement for 22 demand points before, but the government have not fulfilled yet. They blamed, NRB, MOF are not serious to address the stock market problems including SEBON and NEPSE. Likewise, they demanded the true and updated information in timely, thorough information about the CDS System, Mutual Fund provisions, inviting long-term and institutional investors, bring up to date the allotment model for IPO, various effective laws in favor of stock market, development of various infrastructures, trainings, interactions for the general investors including layman etc.
Speakers: Deepak karki, Sunanda Bahadur Shrestha, Prakash Rajauriya and Jeevan Basnet

Nanda Kishor Mundara, President Brokers Association of Nepal

He addressed in the improvement in the economy, decrease in the interest rate, update in the capital gain tax according to the investment duration, brining mutual funds and institutional investors will add smile in the stock market. He said, though it is good news to add brokers outside valley, it has missing various infrastructures as RTS services, proper knowledge hence NEPSE should take it seriously. He commented that "the brokers have to do financial task with just Bank of Kathmandu, however there is no branch of BOK at Chitwan, so how can the stock broker of chitwan perform effective task, therefore the brokers should allow to use more banks for transactions.
Similarly, he suggested Nepse to add more log-in systems for brokerage office to expand the brokerage performance and perform task effectively. The process of additional broker is praiseworthy, however in such market where 23 brokers are not getting good work and still there are lots of hassles to perform the tasks, how can the additional broker will act precisely. He suggested the board to decrease the tax rate of company from 25% to 20%, so that there will be more money for shareholders as dividend and will augment confidence among investors.

Sirus Khambata, Vice President, CDSL India Limited

He explained that this was his third visit to Nepal regarding the implementation of CDS system in Nepal. The process for the CDS is going on with the draft presented by SEBON to MOF and the discussion will be very soon about the establishment of fundamental things. Likewise, the hardware and software has been finalized and the tender will be issued soon. The CDSL company will be independent company and will perform all the tasks smoothly.
The key benefits for stock market in Nepal after the CDS will be
The costs will be reduced to brokers
There will be fast and easy access to stock trading,
Remove physical delivery of stock slips, however will have demat form
Will increase the reach of stock market to remote parts of the country as well
Foreign capital inflow will be attracted if government allows with policies
Mutual Funds will be benefited
At least 25 times volume will be increment in comparison to current volume

"According to our agreement and the regular work we are doing on the CDS system, definitely it will be established with in this September which is good for the stock market of Nepal and the general shareholders as well", he said.

Tanka Paneru, President, Nepal Stock Exchange

We have planned to bring the CDS system and online payment system simultaneously. Likewise, the market will be open for NRN's as per the identification provided by government, trying our best to attract institutional investors as well.
He added that, the additional brokers will be added by the time of CDS implementations; the system of brokers outside the valley is sincerely watching by Nepse and will perform effective tasks as per the need gradually. Likewise, the huge discussion on the system of Market Depth has been finalized or even trialed successfully, however due to various regulatory provisions it is taking time but will act very soon.
Privatization of Nepse along with brining mutual fund is on greater speed, if happened so in time will increase the market efficiency. He advised investors to act decisively in such bearish market and should take this time as a buy period of those fundamental strong companies.

Dr. Surbir Poudyal, Chariman, SEBON

We are trying our best to reform the capital market of Nepal by bringing many investment friendly regulations and inviting institutional investors, CDS system and mutual fund regulations as well. We request general investors to trust in our way, though it is being late due to the long and hasslefull Nepalese bureaucracy. He request with a satire quote "we don't have to think that All the businessman are KALOBAZARI and all the government officials are KAAMCHORI AND BHRASTACHARI".  I mean, we have to trust the others tasks and should be praised for the betterment.


He revealed that, SEBON is doing various training programs in co-ordination of local FNCCI starting from Pokhara very soon. The institutional strength of SEBON will be developed as it has invited the two experts of Securities Board of India (SEBI) in April and have co-ordinate with World Bank for capital development master plan.


"This is really good time to buy shares at stock market as it has plummets hefty, and our capital market is on TAKE UP STAGE which has golden future".



Analysis of the Interaction:

Without any doubt the interaction program will boost the investors' confidence in near term. The discussion has brought down the perception of various experts and regulatory boards viewpoint in a single roof and can be included for the development of capital market. However, the question was lingering in most of the attendant minds why the representative from MINISTRY OF FINANCE and NEPAL RATRA BANK were not presented for discussion in a program organized by SEBON and NEPSE. The growing distress between the SEBON and MOF has failed to implement various key concerns regarding the market development and now this discussion is yet on crisis on deficient of MOF and NRB participation. Though, SEBON chief replied on the questions aroused from open discussion that "Sebon had invited MOF but MOF replied there will not be any role between the interaction of board and investor, as the board is independent on doing so, the answer seems incomplete".

Likewise, the other noticing point was "Most of the speakers take their time to speak in front of podium; however they are not visible in the discussion hall after their speaking time. In such, scenario how can there will be greater participation and fruitful discussion among these expertise.

There happen the flow of perception by speakers from various business including the SEBON and NEPSE, nevertheless there were no 100% commitment by anyone to take action in time. This symbolizes that "Words are the nature of Nepali speakers but the action is always out of the action". But, investors need actions rather than words.
Whatever it is, there is no other option rather than to have trust on the regulatory boards as said by Dr. Poudel to believe on their tasks. Let us believe the implementation of CDS system, mutual fund, institutional investors in stock market (though the process is not finalized and the discussion is on board of these institutions, yet to confirm) along with other assurance of boards will came in action at time with greater effectiveness.


Good Luck!!!!


Bikash 'BGN'
BGN Investmetn & Research






No comments:

Post a Comment