After trading at record high of 1175.38 on 31st August 2008, thereafter Nepse index started to fall down heavily due to several factors including cautious word from Finance Minister of that period (Babu Ram Bhattarai). Though, Nepse recorded some noteworthy surge at short term, at long run it was on downward inclination (Shown by Bold green Straight line). At current, the Nepse index is low of more than 30 months (as shown by red straight line). The trend might go much below the anticipation if similar situation continued. Looking at the Nepse trend, investor might panic on the performance however might be searching for the factual factors that led the investment sentiment down. Stock market is fully based on investors sentiment and said the market sentiment is least understood. The positive sentiment raises the demand of shares and vice-versa. Indeed, the investor's sentiment is such a soft sense that it is affected even by low priority information. There happened to be various events in macro economic situation and micro economic situations including happening in companies itself that led psychology fragile. Following are the key reasons behind the drought of long run bearish rule, however some have short term impact and other very long term.
1. Political inconsistency: Nobody is uninformed about the ongoing political discrepancies that have haunted the investment environment very badly. Stock market is not an exception. Investors get quick reaction to the political ups and down as it craft up the peace and security in the nation, government's ideology towards capital market guided the investor's sentiments as well. However, our political consistency is not parallel and investment environment is on tattered situation. Hence, investors are dubious to invest not only to stock market but other venues of investment too.
2. Restricted Stock market: It will be fair to say that, the easy excess to stock market is restricted to the investor of capital city only. Investors outside the valley have enthusiasm but have to hold extra burden to trade in the market. Government's action is yet behind the bars though words and commitment have flown to expand the network to outside valley long time ago. Investors are limited vis-a-vis to supply of shares in the market. Hence, in this context the demand of shares is terribly weak versus the selling pressures.
3. Titanic supply of shares: One of the key reasons behind the downhill prices is enormous supply of shares in the market in the form of right issue, bonus shares and initial public offerings. Most of the listed companies have increased their paid up capital by issuing new shares in the market through right issues and providing bonus shares to the shareholders. Consequently, the units of share surge and mechanically the prices tend to lower down. "if we look at the year on year the increase of amount of new shares in the following figure, we can find the true picture.
4. IPOs floating in the market: Initial public offerings (IPO) in recent years have tremendously surged. It is obvious that, IPOs shifted the money from secondary market as investors considered it a safe or zero risk game, lucrative return (if allotted) and easy to invest. If we look at the IPO of companies the average demand of shares have rise bymore than 20 times (approx figure). It meant if company is offering Rs. 100 to public it is collecting Rs. 2000 or more from public. This sum of money became idle for investment till the date of return. Hence, investor willing to invest in secondary market kept their money idle for couple of months.
If we analyze the following figure we can find that, the supply of shares in the market has surged extremely year on year from 2004/05.
(Public issue amount approved by SEBON year on year. This includes ordinary shares, right shares, debentures, preference share etc..)
The figure indicates the permission given by SEBON to issue new share has tremendously increase from the fiscal year 2005/06 to 2008/09. The amount look as if it will go more in 2009/10 as yet there are more than 6 months to go. The trend clearly reflects that, there were huge supplies of shares in the market during 2005/06 to 2008/09 and these were especially in the form of right share, initial public offerings etc. However, if we think positive the enthusiasm of investors towards stock market has surge vigorously from the same year and even novice individual at the market aspire to grasp the investment opportunities.
5. Rigid Rules and Regulations:
The capital market is running on rules and regulations imposed by regularities bodies. However, investors at current phase are completely not satisfied with the provisions on
a. Margin Lending provision: The NRB by adopting the new policy on margin lending in 2008/09 made a provision under which loan can be extended up to 50% of average price of the shares in the last 180 days or latest market price, whichever is lower. In the year 2008-09 additional provision of calling further collateral within 21 days was introduced when the value of shares pledge as collateral falls below the loan amount. Such provision protected bankers and financial institutions against risk through controlling un-desired credit of margin nature. (Line to Line abstracted from monetary policy 2009/10). This rule was brought in to action to implement the sound financial health of financial market in terms of risk and creditworthiness, however affected the stock market in long run. And yet this rigid rule is not deleted even the market plunged to ground level. However, very recently Nepal Rastra Bank (NRB) has directed banks and financial institutions to reduce the limit of renewal of margin lending (lending against collateral of shares) by 50 per cent, which can be termed as positive step but not at par on investors' expectation.
b. Conversion of 19% promoter share to pubic share: Securities Board of Nepal (SEBON) in consent of NRB has given approval of floating 19% of promoters' shares in the form of ordinary shares. This will balance the public holding to maximum of 49% and promoters holding 51% in the company. However, this will increase the supply of shares at extreme in the market within limited investors. Hence, investors got thrilled with the decision and behave as the price will fall in near term after the floating of these 19% shares in the market and were giving selling orders even in bearish rule.
c. High Interest rate: The interest rate in Nepal is at their height in the period of international interest going down, hence this has also influence over the capital market. The liquidity is short and interest rate tends to high. Banks are providing more than 10% on the deposits and taking more than 14% on the loans provided depending upon category of the subject. Capital market investors will definitely choose the higher return by any means on their investment, simply depositing in high interest rate rather than downhill market.
On the other side, taking loan from the bank to invest in shares is very difficult. The provision of loan against shares has impeded the investment in capital market taking loan. Likewise, these loan interests are tremendously high and no individual will desire to take loan at high rate and invest in bearish stock market.
(Fig: Nepse index at first session of every year 1 jan 07 to 10 Dec 09)
If we termed the broad benchmark Nepse index as the return in stock market (might not be true in case of individual scrip), we can discover the yearly return from 2007 to end of 2008 year is more than 34% (Exceptionally high return in investment). However, the data will surprise us there after as in 2009 it was just diminutive of 0.89% and sadly it was in negative at current phase (Dec 10 2009) with more than 21% loss in stock investment. Hence we can term the scenario is much more worse than actually we have imagined.
6. Economic Backdrop: Our economy is one of the world's poorest economies where deadly economic backdrops as low GDP, high poverty, high inflation, trade deficit, poor investment environment, lack of infrastructures, poor corporate governance and the most international dependent. Hence, in this context how can our capital market perform sound and healthy? Our capital market is also one of the deficient markets in terms of technology, human resource and so on. Hence, capital market which is one of the integral parts of national economy depends upon the overall progress of economic environment.
7. Alternative Investment Vehicle: Most of the people at contemporary period perceiving that, there is shift of investment to different venues such as Futures and Commodities market, realty sectors, deposits and also international investment. People who used to be active market player at stock market are also diverting their investment portfolio to these sectors as well for the prospect of lucrative return. Hence, demand of shares in the plain sailing stock market tends to lower down parallel to average turnover and number of transactions.
8. Companies Fundamentals: Companies fundamentals are itself weak in one hand and the other the corporate governance is yet fragile in home nation. As per the NRB act to increase the paid-up capital, companies are just issuing right share to increase their paid-up capital however sadly those capitals collect have not generated return in the same ratio and it feels companies failed to utilize the collected money at their utmost level. Hence, companies issuing right shares seem week in giving return in next year that will certainly weaken the investment sentiment in terms of fundaments. There is still high P\E ratio, low EPS, average Book value per shares and maximum price to book value ratio. In this context, the fundamentals and price is not in co-relation letting the concerned investors to think twice before investing.
Though profit have surged year on year of most of the companies it has to be distributed to huge shareholders as companies have already increased their paid-up capital. Hence, EPS tends to low and companies provide fewer dividends.
Technological and Human Resources Lagging: Our capital market is one of the poorest markets in terms of technology and experienced human resources. The system of automated machine only for brokers happened be our latest technology. We are yet on backdrop of this kind of technology that will spur out market health. The Central Depository System (CDS) is in process and if it will come in to existence the market might boost to new height. However, this seems more ambiguous very recently though government is positive towards bringing it soon. The similar case is to the human resource and we can find from the words of governing bodies that there is lack of skilled and experience human resource in the field.
10 Others: The other factor is international crisis that is hampering Nepal in terms of employment, remittance, trade. Likewise, surge in gold prices and weak dollar, fluctuation of oil prices hampered our economy. Investment without thorough knowledge is also great difficulty at our capital market including frequently changing rule of law, market dominated by financial companies and our psychology to follow the herd without any true information.
Remedies to call bulls again:
Though there were noteworthy positive signs at secondary market during recent week, it will be like to "pull the wool over somebody's eyes" and say bears are gone. However, looking at all the disappointing factors at Nepal Stock Exchange's performance in long run the bears will outweighed the bulls again if there won't be any change at policy level or economic level. Hence, investing in stock market is suspicious task as there are lots of un-expected things to happen on political as well as economical hampering the stock market.
If following points came in to action, our stock market will not only be healthy but will run thoroughly in system with fair price level.
· Investment decisions by any investors have to be taken through detail analysis of company, its prospects and return and risk involvement but not in haste.
· Governing bodies should implement rules and regulations in favor of stock market to make it more efficient and systematic. Recently, the amendment in loan against share (so called margin lending) and issue of promoter share conversion is necessary. Similarly, the provisions should be static for some fixed duration but not volatile within short span of time.
· Stock market access should be reached to overall cities of Nepal, hence there will be huge participation and number of shares will definitely narrowed to the number of investors. For this, the huge responsibilities goes to SEBON and NEPSE for bringing such provisions and spreading general awareness, trainings etc.
· Central Depositor System (CDS) should be enacted as soon as possible and expand the market in parallel.
· Political soundness leads to economic prosperity and now it is just the big foundation of our stock market. There must be political stability and overall economic situations should be sound and progressive. Even though it seems over ambiguous looking at current situation, there are hopes and faith all around.
· The role of SEBON and NEPSE should be systematic and effective in regulating stock market, bringing favorable rules and regulations, developing their strength in terms of technology and human resources, stopping the un-necessary acts (out of law acts) that is happening or might happen in the stock market.
· There are other micro factors as good corporate governance, investors awareness in aggressive manner is essence along with fast and easy access to the companies' information.
By Bikash Chaudhary "BGN"
Originally Published in New Business Age (December 2009)




nice article, keep on writting with such articles, we all like it
ReplyDelete