January 16, 2010

Value Vs Growth Investing

There are many investment strategies bring into play by a myriad of both individual and professional investor while investing in capital markets. However, simply these all investment strategies can be put down together in two baskets: first basket for value investing and the next growth investing.
There are great investors as Benjamin Graham, Warren Buffet, William j Ruane, Irving Kahn, Bill Miller and others became very successful in their life from Value investing while investors like Peter Lynch, Philip Fisher….were renowned for growth investing.
However, both the investing principles have their own idiosyncratic and money-making features to lure the wide array of investors with broad psychologies. But many featured them in to single basket to triumph the lucrative profit. As Warren Buffet have stated that there is no theoretical difference between the concept of value and growth ("Growth and Value investing are joined at the hip") is consideration of the concept of an asset's intrinsic value. Similarly, Peter Lynch pioneered a hybrid of growth and value investing with what is now renowned as "Growth at a reasonable price strategy". Let use explore the true meaning of value and growth investing.
Value Investing:

Value investing simply dictates, buy the stocks when they are trading at their lows and sell it when priced high. Every investor aspires to do the same and looks as it is the simple phenomenon to confine profits at hand. Though it seems simple and easy, majority of investors failed to do this as encountered by psychological concern.
The principal trait of value investing lies on undervalued stocks that plummets with the news on feeble quarterly profits, changes in management and its shabby decisions, restricted products or short term underrating, any bad news or market downturn that will not affect company in long run etc. Basically, it's about finding an outstanding company at a sensible price rather than general companies at a bargain price. A value investor will evaluate the key reasons behind the slump of stock price of renowned and profitable companies and if the investors believed the market price has overreacted (as it almost always does), then he will pick up those shares at a lower price with an optimistic view of market correction. In addition, a value investor does not look for companies who have yet to prove the productivity or thumbs up image in the market. And a true value investor would never invest in a company that does not generate money for him.
There are many ways to determine the share price of company while making value investing decision, the widely used method is to look at the Price to Earnings Ratio (P/E) of the company. The P/E ratio compares the market price of stocks at exchange and the amount of earnings generated by the company. The lower the ratio of P/E the better the price is for buying. However, this might not be true in all the cases and must not be used as the sole measure for evaluating stocks. In the same way, ratios like Price to Book Value (P/B), price to cash flow, and have high dividend yield are the quantifiable facts to determine whether the stock is undervalued or not. However, there are some risks at value investing.
·         While evaluating stocks at bear market which are undervalued at one time, the prices might fall dip further with the market slump.
·         Stock prices at bull market that appeared overvalued at one time, the prices might rocket further along with the market.
·         There is no systematic or standard to valued a stocks in terms of P/E, P/B, and Price to Cash flow that can define the rewarding return.
Growth Investing
Growth investing is widely used investment strategy that exhibit signs of above average growth even if the share price appears expensive in terms of key indicators as P/E ratio, P/B ratio. In typical, growth investing contrast with the value investing. The fundamental goal of growth investing is to buy a stock no matter what its price is at market and sell it for more prices. And this strategy is much more akin to gambling than investing as there is always high probability of losing the money. However, growth investing is also prominent for higher return in short period of time.
There are many ways to execute a growth investment strategy. Some of these include emerging markets, recovery shares, blue chips scrip, smaller companies, special situations and many more that really can deliver higher prospects of return. The risk of value investing can be:
·         Tips from various sources, rumors, hype and market hysteria might impinge on stock loss.
·         Difficult to find the price of company to buy and the timing of selling
·         The market downturn hit growth stocks far harder than value stocks
·         There is always potential for total loss.

Value investing at Nepse
We general investors at Nepal Stock Exchange, consciously or unconsciously is following the above stated strategies. Sometimes it might take hand of growth strategy and for the other times it might restrain value investing. This is time of bear crawl at our stock market where bulls have been disappeared since two years.  Investors might be thinking this is the right time to buy shares from stock market, where the strategy of value investing might exist. Similarly, the market is also going through volatile situation where continuous surge of stock price too exist maintaining for growth investing.
Let us pore over the core fundamentals of some key companies (which we called blue chip scrip) to analyze either these stocks are in fact growth stocks or value stocks at current phase.
Standard Chartered Bank Nepal, which is regarded as the high yield and most profitable stock at secondary market now have P/E ratio 29.73 times , P/B ratio 9.44 times and yield 50% bonus and 50% cash dividend. The price during the year fluctuate from Rs. 4600 (Jan 5) to Rs. 5394 (Sep 28, 09 before book closure date). During the period it went as high as Rs. 6500 and low of Rs. 4220.
Nabil Bank the next blue chip scrip has too high P/E 34.82 T, low P/B ratio 11 T while high dividends yield of 50% bonus and 30% cash dividend. Price fluctuate from Rs. 3409 (Jan 5, 09) to Rs. 4300 (Aug 31, 09 before the book closure date). During the period it went as high as Rs. 52410 and low of Rs. 3050.
Similarly if we analyze most of the company and their fundamentals we can find high P/E, low P/B and just marginal yield in terms of EPS. This features symbolizes, we can't termed these scrip as value investing at current phase though the market has dipped very low however any stocks can be termed as growth stocks at contemporary phase evaluating their performance at Nepse. Amid the worry of price fall in the market the market price is yet higher in comparison to the fundamental of company. This meant, the recent price of most of the stocks is yet overvalued in the market price and for value investing prices needs to be slump down further more.
I believed, if the same warren buffet or Benjamin graham or Bill Miller had to decide investing in Nepal Stock Exchange (Who are famous for their value investing), they will turned their back witnessing the fundamentals just opposed to their investing style.
Finally, the best method of investing could be mixed approach of both types of investing strategy. One can peak stocks from secondary market that have low P/E, High P/B, high EPS, good dividend yield and have growth prospects as well. The accumulation of pros from each of the strategies and reduce as many of the cons as possible will be the optimum solutions. However, it is found that investors at Nepali stock market do not take trouble to analyze the fundamentals of company in details and hence the crowd psychology, whim or nasty decisions took the price far higher in terms of actual fundamentals. And the result is, we are now having hefty loss in share market. It is all due to our partial knowledge, hasty investment strategy and investment without true information on fundamentals of company.


By Bikash Chaudhary
Stock Analyst at Jamb Technologies (www.nepalsharemarket.com).


Published in New Business Age (January 2010)

No comments:

Post a Comment